Segregation and Charter Schools: A Reader

In The link between charter school expansion and increasing segregation, Iris C. Rotberg highlights that problems exist in both re-segregation of schools in the U.S. and the rise of charter schools as separate and interrelated forces.

Schools in the U.S. are re-segregating, regardless of type—public, private, and charter.

And charter schools are not creating the education reform charter advocates claim, with one failure of the charter movement being segregating students by race and class.

Thus, it is important to focus on the evidence that shows the need to reconsider how to address segregation and the flawed support continuing for expanding charter schools.

Let me offer below a reader for such evidence:

Some key points from Rotberg include the following:

#1. There is a strong link between school choice programs and an increase in student segregation by race, ethnicity, and income….

#2. The risk of segregation is a direct reflection of the design of the school choice program….

#3. Even beyond race, ethnicity, and income, school choice programs result in increased segregation for special education and language-minority students, as well as in increased segregation of students based on religion and culture….

I am not under the illusion that by modifying federal policy on charter schools we would solve the basic problem of segregation. But we could at least eliminate one factor exacerbating it: the federal pressure on states and school districts to proliferate charter schools, even in situations that might lend themselves to increased segregation. Instead of serving as a cheerleader for charter schools, the federal government might instead support diversity in schools and, at the same time, publicize the risks of increased student stratification.

Even apart from the negative effect of increased segregation, justifying federal advocacy of charter school expansion is difficult when there’s no evidence that charter schools, on average, are academically superior to traditional public schools or even that they can be more innovative given the Common Core State Standards and the testing associated with them.

8 thoughts on “Segregation and Charter Schools: A Reader

  1. Pingback: Segregation and Charter Schools: A Reader – @ THE CHALK FACE

  2. Pingback: SC, Choose OK, Not FL: Failing Students with Failed Policy | the becoming radical

  3. Pingback: Schneider’s Ten Reform Claims: A Reader | the becoming radical

  4. Pingback: GreenvilleOnline: SC should choose Oklahoma, not Florida | the becoming radical

  5. Pingback: How the Billionaire Kingpins of School Privatization Got Stopped in Their Own Back Yard | Millionaire Books

  6. Pingback: Resisting Fatalism in Post-Truth Trumplandia: Charter Schools and the End of Accountability by Garn Press Author Paul Thomas - Garn Press

  7. Pingback: BOOK EXCERPT: From Trumplandia - "Resisting Fatalism in Post-Truth Trumplandia: Charter Schools and the End of Accountability" - Garn Press

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s